Should Euthanasia be legalized? Discuss
Everyone knows life is treasure that money can not buy, but sadly nowadays people spend money to buy death which is euthanasia with or without conscious. "Euthanasia Acts means that psychosocial factor, rather than strictly terminal illness, are being used to open the door to assisted suicide" (The Ottawa citizen, 2012) Euthanasia is also called as "mercy killing" . Mercy killing is morally incorrect , because when voluntary turns to involuntary, euthanasia may become a "slippery slope" to murder. Many proponent and opponent of euthanasia, but there are only few countries have legalized euthanasia such as Switzerland, the Netherlands , Belgium and so on. People always human have right to die , what if people is not willing to undertake euthanasia, but also do not have the strength to against? It no longer about right to die, it may involve right to live. Finally, it will turn to murder but without other people notice. This would affect the vulnerable society in a passive way. Therefore, if euthanasia has been legalized, it , a lot of issues will pop up such as potential abuse, as well as the pain past their family member.
Firstly, legalized euthanasia would cause potential abuse by mislead patients go through euthanasia with or without consult patients.The advance medical technology is able to enhance human life and quality of life by Palliative and rehabilitation centers which really help patient to release their pain or give them a better life. (Dr. Maisie M)Proponent o f euthanasia always stand for "people have the right to die" because they have the "right to refuse medical treatment". While "The professionals recognize that if pain is controlled, as it can be in virtually all cases, very few terminally ill people ask to be put to death."(Lewistown, NY.) Therefore, euthanasia will from voluntary turns to involuntary which become potential abuse which Holland is a example. Holland is regard as a civilized country worldwidely which euthanasia is active legalized here. Unfortunately, A disturbing findings of a investigation of euthanasia have published by Dutch government in 1991 "In 1990, 1,030 Dutch patients were killed WITHOUT THEIR CONSENT. And of 22,500 deaths due to withdrawal of life support, 63% (14,175 patients) were denied medical treatment WITHOUT THEIR CONSENT. Twelve percent(1,701 patients) were mentally competent but were NOT CONSULTED. " The figure above is pathetic,If the medical technology can help patient feel better, as if the pain can be relieve, most patients would like to continue live. How doctors or family members will rather choose not to use it but by misconvince them to undertake euthanasia? No matter is the family financial problem or doctor his or her self lack of responsibility or the hospital want to save resource in order to give to other more "more hopful"patient, these are can not be the excuses of taking other people's life. This is absolutely morally wrong, nobody has the right to do so. This is also against the doctors or hospital's principle of saving people's life. Doctor suppose to be angers to save people in their best way, while they become evils to cut down people's live and take them away. Sadly say that if the euthanasia has been legalized, the "right to die" will turn into "right to kill".
Secondly, family member need to carry more emotional pain when their beloved one undertake euthanasia. Patient usually has rather low ability to anti pressure during treatment period. Especially terminal ill patient are often suffer a great pain come with medical treatment, and most people can not endure it, at the time, people are seeking for a way to relief the pain, which rather than taking medicine to relief the pain temporary, first ting come to their mind is death. While for their family , they would willing to pay anything to enhance their beloved one's life, even they usually respect patient's decisions. A documentary of "The Suicide Tourist", a retired teacher American Craig Ewert, 59, choose to end his life after five months suffering with neurological disease. Other than the man is suffering with the great pain during treatment time. Do you notice his wife is happy during the time he was alive, she never showed her impatient to his husband even he totally lost the ability to take care of himself. No matter how hard it is , his wife still willing to do anything without any grievance. She always has a light smile on her face. However, there are two shots, firstly, when doctor confirmed he is died after took the medicine, she was crying out. Secondly, when she recorded the memory with her husband she was again crying and crying. No one would really understand how much pain in her heart. Her husband will never know how much pain he leave to his wife and sons. The emotional pain is far great than psychical pain, because "Pain caused by emotional distress is more deeply felt and longer lasting than that caused by physical injuries, according to a new study. "(Irvine , 2008)Since the family is the traditional place where life begins and is nurtured, euthanasia would cause great emotional pain to the family who lost their beloved one in this way.
The last but not the least, euthanasia not the only way to relief pain, and it is against the nature of death. Many people out there are suffering with disease as well, such as Stephen Hawking who is a greatest physiologist suffered with Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis in his whole life. Can you say that he is not painful ? But he dedicate his whole life to physics world, and he achieved it. He did not give up until now. It's possible to fight with pain with disease. When other people have not given you up but yourself, it's pathetic. Lost ability to take care of self is not shame,but go through euthanasia is not the way to show a person's dignity as well.